| Surname | Forenames | Rel. | Father | Mother | Abode | Day | Month | Year | Notes |
| IBBOTSON | George | S | Henry | Maria | Norbriggs | 8 | October | 1837 | |
| IBBOTSON | Maria | D | Henry | Maria | Sheffield | 10 | May | 1829 | |
| IBBS | Sarah | Di | Elizabeth | Stavely | 22 | February | 1784 | Illegitimate, father Edward Maden] of Chesterfield | |
| IBBS | William | Si | Elizabeth | Staveley | 24 | June | 1776 | Illegitimate | |
| INCE | Beatrix | D | Henry | 26 | November | 1590 | |||
| INCE | Edward | S | Henry | 2 | May | 1588 | |||
| INCE | Margaret | D | Henry | 9 | September | 1579 | |||
| INCE | Mary | D | Henry | Staveley | 11 | June | 1582 | ||
| INCE | Peter | Si | Margarett | 23 | September | 1603 | Illegitimate, putative father Samuel Gilbert | ||
| INCE | Robert | S | Henry | Staveley | 17 | April | 1585 | ||
| INGMANTHORPE | Elizabeth | D | 14 | June | 1562 | ||||
| IRWIN | James | S | Erasmus | Sarah | Stavely | 1 | January | 1792 | |
| ISON | George | S | William | Elizabeth | Woodthorpe | 30 | June | 1834 | |
| ISON | Mary | D | William | Elizabeth | Woodthorpe | 13 | March | 1836 | |
| IVINGS | Francis | S | Joseph | Anne | Woodthorpe | 14 | April | 1782 | |
| IVINGS | Joseph | S | Joseph | Anne | Woodthorpe | 18 | June | 1780 | |